Visit Citebite Deep link provided by Citebite
Close this shade
Source:  http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/foreign/richardspencer/sept06/panda.htm

Richard Spencer is The Daily Telegraph's China Correspondent. He lives in Beijing with his wife and three children, aged 14, 12 and 9.

Technorati Profile

Savage pandas and pyjamas

Posted by Richard Spencer on 21 Sep 2006  at 12:54 
Tags: , , , , ,

Two lighter stories yesterday, one which made the newspaper, the other which didn't, nicely highlighted the differences between Beijing and Shanghai, I thought.

Panda
Pandas are not always so huggable

The story that made the paper was the curious incident of the panda in the day-time - the drunk visitor to Beijing from Henan who decided to go panda-hugging at the zoo and got mauled. He bit back, providing a memorable Chinese equivalent to the old newsman's dictum that while dog bites man isn't news, man bites dog is.

The story that didn't make was a survey of modern Shanghai life which revealed that the thing locals liked least about living there was their own habit of going out in their pyjamas. Now this is a common habit all over China, of course.

Certainly, the morning and evening summer scenery in my own alley is locals of all ages, admittedly most prominently those on the wrong side of 45, heading off to the bath-house, the loos, or even the kebab stand in their nightgear. Afterwards, they take the evening air with their friends, and play Chinese chess, similarly attired.

The Shanghai dislike of this is not because they don't do it - 41 per cent of respondents to the survey said family members were guilty some or all of the time.

But clearly there is a more uptight Shanghai, that anyone who has strolled down HuaiHai Lu has noticed strongly on display: leave the past, and the elderly, and the local behind; we are not Chinese, we are international, we belong to a cosmopolitan country called London-Hong Kong-New York-Paris-Frankfurt-Shanghai, which is where our Armani carrier bags tell us we live. We DON'T go out in our pyjamas. Ever.

The common complaints of Beijingers or foreign residents of the capital in such surveys - spitting, queue-barging, smelly taxis, street sellers hassling you to buy fake DVDs - do not appear in the Shanghai survey list. I assume that this is because both surveyors and Shanghainese would refuse to acknowledge such style crimes exist there.

Compare that with the treatment of Mr Zhang, the man who embarrassed himself in the panda enclosure. I half expected to see a diatribe about the dangers of drunkenness, or the uncouthness of the residents of Henan (where he came from; often the butt of country bumpkin type jokes), or how embarrassing it was to have someone show himself up like this somewhere lots of foreign
tourists go. But no. He was taken to hospital, patched up, and let go.

No charge of being drunk and disorderly, or breach of the peace, or any of the things that I suspect would have got him a caution if not a visit to the magistrates in Britain. Just one of those things, the newspaper treatment seemed to say, nothing special, bit of a laugh, bit of an idiot. Something to brighten the endless toil of life. Fansong fansong - relax, relax, as no-one would ever say in Shanghai.

On the other hand, imagine if a survey of foreigners found that people wearing pyjamas in Beijing's hutongs was one of THEIR biggest gripes about the city? The new vogue term in the Chinese blogosphere is the Internet Mob- angry online groups who gather to maul adulterers, cat-killers, dislikable foreigners etc.

Imagine the Internet Mob that would go after foreigners if we tried to question the inalienable right of Aunty Zhou to sit with her friends in the neighbourhood committee watching the world go by in her floral nightie every evening? Angry youth would have nothing on it. Of course, substitute "Shanghainese" for "foreigners" and I suspect the rage would be even worse.

P.S. Do I wear pyjamas out now I live in a hutong? That's for you to find out.


3 comments

Show most recent:

Fangsong, not Fansong!

Nic G 
22 Sep 2006 03:02

Dear Richard - I have seen the photos you took and they show me that your house must be about 50 yards south of our apartment. I live in that ugly yellow-and-grey seven storey building with the fence around it. It's nice enough inside through; do drop by for a cup of tea.

Report this comment

panda hugging foreigners

Chris  
22 Sep 2006 03:47

You don't have to look far to find an example of foreigners complaining about people wearing pyjamas and much more besides- just check out chinarant.com a collection of puerile, silly and at times racist rants on China by some of the middle kingdom's less impressive foreign residents. You do get the odd interesting comment or story though- particularly stories of a trend towards more violence towards foreigners etc.

I do quite like the concept of the internet mob and hope that I am not going to get mauled for pointing you to the above- I am firmly of the belief that all news sources are valid in some way or another. It is amazing how the internet is such a source of relief of frustration in this country for the Chinese- I don't think that it is just a matter of the political climate, they are generally a non-confrontational people and the internet does give room for venting in a nice and anonymous way.

Nice to see the panda getting his own back. I usually think of them as rather dull (but cute) creatures that are not even smart enough to reproduce properly so my respect for this particular panda has gone up enormously.

Report this comment

PJs

Mark Lean  
22 Sep 2006 08:42

Mr. Spencer, I think the real question should be: do you wear pyjamas at all?

Report this comment

Comment on this post

You must be logged on to leave a comment.